This semester I had a professor that got off on interesting, related tangents every now and again. The class was Internet Law and there was some discussion of the regulatory frameworks of broadcast and cable television. At some point he mentioned his (and his wife's) approach to television with their kids: two hours a week. That might have been total screen time, so computer and television time. This professor also mentioned that his kids didn't have a gaming system, would never be allowed to have TV's or computers in their rooms, and couldn't see PG-13 movies until they are 13.It made me think about our approach to TV with Hannah and Maddie. One thing that has occurred to me is that Maddie, having an older sister, is going to see more television that Hannah did at that age. I think we kept Hannah's time down pretty well for her first 18 months to two years.
As most folks know, the American Academy of Pediatricians recommends that children under two watch absolutely no television or videos. I don't know many parents (if I know any) that follow that guideline. We dutifully follow health advice and buy hand-sanitizer buy the gallon, but this recommendation basically gets laughed off as impractical. Or we simply don't believe it. After all kids don't get running noses or fevers from watching TV. Anything adverse is internal, far more subtle. So following that kind of recommendation requires a different level of faith in pediatricians.
More faith than we have, apparently. We own several Kipper videos, one Spot video, Baby Mozart, a few Veggie Tales videos, and a couple others. We also often check out Little Einstein movies, Hannah had a huge Thomas phase that has now been in remission for a little while, and Maddie has chosen Dora (my arch-nemesis) a couple of times. Hannah used to watch a couple of shows on PBS, but the kids almost never ask to watch regular shows, just videos. The kids watch Nature with me on Sundays, or at least the first twenty minutes and then come in and out until the end. I love it, and sometimes the kids really like it too. When we have a video I try to skip the commercials for other videos, that eases my guilty conscience a little. While the quality of PBS shows leaves much to be desired, at least the kids don't see commercials.
I don't think the kids watch a ton of television, but they are definitely over the two hours a week...at least it's not an order of magnitude, right? It's just so easy to plug the kids into the TV if you need to get something done. And I think that's why most of us do it. If I remember correctly, I had a post about the Baby Einstein refund. I can't imagine that many folks think any videos are really educational (although that is the claim being made), so maybe it's parental laziness on our part or again that lack of faith in the AAP's for things that don't have symptoms.
Natalie and I have tried watching three Disney length features: Peter Pan, Cinderella, and the Fox and the Hound. Hannah's kind of a sensitive soul. So Peter Pan and the Fox and the Hound were too violent for her. We finished them at her request, but she was well snuggled for the intense parts. Cinderella was too adult for her. Ever tried explaining a wicked step-mother to a four year old? It's interesting to note that Maddie doesn't get scared during the parts when Hannah does. I would guess that's because Maddie doesn't understand enough to know the parts are scary (involving an imminent threat to a human life), while Hannah does. So, it's clear the stories are far over her head, so I think we can hold off a while longer until she can really enjoy them.
Media is one of my biggest sources of anxiety as a parent and I'm realizing that the more mixed in age our kids get as our family grows the more thoughtful I'll need to be about it. If you have any comments, fire away.
[While I was writing this Maddie asked to watch a Kipper video and a Noah's Ark video, and grabbed a DVD case and said,"I want to watch right now." Luckily I managed to get her to take a nap. Maybe staring at a screen to write a blog post isn't setting a great example...]