Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts

Saturday, June 11, 2011

Review: "Spoilt Rotten: The Toxic Cult of Sentimentality" by Theodore Dalrymple

Sentimentality does no harm when it is confined to the private sphere....But as the wellspring of public policy, or of public reaction to events or social problems, it is as disastrous as it is prevalent.

Theodore Dalrymple, an Englishman, spent the bulk of his career as a psychiatrist/prison doctor for many years and has been writing for quite a while as well.  His work gives an interesting perspective to this book, and I suspect his other writing as well.

First, Dalrymple is not saying that emotions are bad.  In fact he says emotions are "necessary to all cognitive activity and rational thought.  Without an emotional stance to the world, one would do nothing, think nothing and seek nothing."

But the book's premise is that we've let emotion run amok.  More precisely, we've let public expressions of emotions run amok.  "It is no longer enough to shed a tear in private over the death of Little Nell; it is necessary to do so, or the modern equivalent, in full public view.... In such a world, what is done or happens in private is not done or has not happened at all, at least not in the fullest sense."  For Facebook users, think about how many times you've been "asked" to prove your support for child-abuse victims, Jesus, or America by reposting.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

This is Achievement's Plan?

I've seen this in the newspaper for a few weeks now, and every time I chuckle a bit.  I suppose they don't say it's a "great" plan.  Maybe I'll feel better when we try to get a home loan in a few years.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Shock-jocks and the "Reality Beat"

I was watching Bill Moyers Journal last night, and there was a segment about crazy things right-wing shock-jocks (Limbaugh, Reagan, Savage, Beck) had said on the air. Although I honestly think they're all certified scoundrels, I got a bit defensive because I'm politically somewhere on the right. I felt that way for maybe a minute. The quotes the Moyers people played were outrageous and, well...shocking...things all those guys had said darn well better be offensive to the people reading this blog. If these guys believe every word that spews from their mouths, they are what you would most properly call "evil" people. Read a transcript if you'd like.
For the record, I don't think the shock-jocks believe themselves, at least not deep down. If I had to talk to people every day for a living, I'd probably say some stupid things too. But if I started saying evil things, hopefully I would have the sense to quit and get a real job.

The next segment was about "journalists on the 'reality beat'." Apparently it was now Bill Moyers turn to be an idiot:

"This helps us understand why the facts about Sarah Palin meant nothing when she suddenly materialized on the public stage, like Cinderella at the ball. You could see the convention delegates awed by the magical moment when the small-town girl, church-going hockey mom, mentored by her pastor to think upon the story of the biblical Queen Esther, became an overnight star. Leaping past "go" to the pinnacle of politics and the ultimate goal the cover of "People" magazine.

No wonder reality-based journalists are having a hard time with this story. Mythology is not their beat. But in the imagination of her tribe, Sarah Palin achieved an almost immaculate conception. Her lack of experience matters not to them. Nor do they care that her past is filled with contradictions, and nothing the press reports, no matter how grounded in fact, can shake their faith."

As he described this new media darling, I was reminded of the first media darling: Barack Obama. Am I to draw from this that an appearance on People magazine should dimish my regard for a potential VP...If that's true for VP's, I wonder if it applies to presidential candidates? As irrational as that may be, the astute Bill Moyers' answer must be "no."

The way he described Palin mirrors Obama's story so well: overnight star, convention delegates awed by the magical moment(s), achieved almost an immaculate conception, and [his] lack of experience matters not to them. Am I wrong about any of those? If I am, please point out my mistake. Maybe Bill Moyers said all those things about Barack Obama in a previous show. If he did I couldn't find it. Maybe as a primitive member of a "tribe" I'm just not smart enough to figure out where to look.

It seems that despite Mr. Moyers precious "reality beat", he too has the ability to pick out words like a hitman picks out his loaded guns. And look out reality, he knows how to use 'em! The funny thing is that I'll still watch his show before anything on Fox or CNN. Apparently nothing can shake my faith.