Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Books. Show all posts

Thursday, September 22, 2011

Review: "A Chair for My Mother" by Vera B. Williams

As usual, I end up reviewing a book from my own childhood. This one is another classic. Again, it's another urban book, but that never stuck out to me as a kid.

For those that don't already know this story, it's all about hard-nosed economics. OK, maybe not all about hard-nosed economics, but that plays no small part. The story is about a hard-working, poor family that's struggling to make ends meet, but never complains.  The little girl who narrates the story tells us that their old home burned down, taking all their possessions but sparing her grandmother and their cat.  The neighborhood comes together to help them furnish a new place, but they stil go more than a year trying to save up for a soft chair.  While it may not be the end of the world, imagine going a year without a single soft chair (or sofa/couch) in your house.  The family, all very upbeat, managed to stock away spare change in a giant jar.  After saving change for over a year they finally look for and find the chair of their dreams.

I'm decidedly in the camp that wants to be inspired by the books I read. And I want my kids to read books that inspire them too, that show people who encounter set backs but who have positive outlooks and work their way out even if it means saving for over a year.  So I like reading this book to my girls. They can see that families are defined by love and mutual support, and that they have to save up for things, sometimes even simple things like chairs.

Saturday, June 11, 2011

Review: "Spoilt Rotten: The Toxic Cult of Sentimentality" by Theodore Dalrymple

Sentimentality does no harm when it is confined to the private sphere....But as the wellspring of public policy, or of public reaction to events or social problems, it is as disastrous as it is prevalent.

Theodore Dalrymple, an Englishman, spent the bulk of his career as a psychiatrist/prison doctor for many years and has been writing for quite a while as well.  His work gives an interesting perspective to this book, and I suspect his other writing as well.

First, Dalrymple is not saying that emotions are bad.  In fact he says emotions are "necessary to all cognitive activity and rational thought.  Without an emotional stance to the world, one would do nothing, think nothing and seek nothing."

But the book's premise is that we've let emotion run amok.  More precisely, we've let public expressions of emotions run amok.  "It is no longer enough to shed a tear in private over the death of Little Nell; it is necessary to do so, or the modern equivalent, in full public view.... In such a world, what is done or happens in private is not done or has not happened at all, at least not in the fullest sense."  For Facebook users, think about how many times you've been "asked" to prove your support for child-abuse victims, Jesus, or America by reposting.

Sunday, April 3, 2011

Review: Who Really Cares - Arthur Brooks

This book has been on my list for a while.  I heard a podcast of Arthur Brooks speaking at a BYU forum some time ago, and thought I'd read the book.

Brooks starts out describing his transition from progressivism to conservativism and how it related to his research on charity.  Like the young Brooks, I think I would have assumed that modern liberals would be more likely to donate money and time to various causes.  I would have thought more conservatives would hand out the old "Give a man a fish" line and call it a day.  After all, when it comes to talk of caring for the poor and needy modern day Democrats seem to have the microphone well in hand.

Not so fast...

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Mama Bears vs. Tiger Mothers

Natalie and I listened the the audiobook version of Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother by Amy Chua, a book you've heard of, no doubt.  The book was funny and read by Chua, which was a plus.  It's a memoir, not a parenting guide.  Chua believes there is a high expectation, high pressure form of parenting she call "Chinese" which produces capable, strong, intelligent children, and a low pressure, low expectation form of parenting she calls "Western" that produces incompetent, weak, dull children.  She also worries about the generational degradation--children raised by the children of immigrants have lower educational and economic attainment than their parents. 

The book deals with how her beliefs on parenting holds up while she and her husband raise their two girls.  The youngest girl doesn't get with the program.  Her girls are excellent students and accomplished musicians, the second less "accomplished" than the first.  They are driven to succeed...by Chua.  Chua's a bit crazy, yes, but she clearly loves her girls.  She also loves achievement, she loves excellence.  More dangerously, she loves having her children be Number One.  From our discussions about the book, Natalie and I agree that's where she goes off the rails, her emphasis on comparison in her definition of success.  Chua alludes to an awareness of this when she discusses her great concern over the abysmal intelligence ranking of Samoyeds.  (They bought one before Chua heard of the rankings.)  But she never addresses the issue head on.  Consistently the goal she set for her girls was to be the best: first in the class at everything, best in a piano competition, etc.  Not objectively good, but comparatively good (although the objectively good part gets brought in naturally in the quest).  Not working hard to be your best, but the best.


But, I see a lot of good in what Chua calls the Chinese approach.

Monday, October 18, 2010

Review: Dimity Duck by Jane Yolen & Sebastien Braun

We just checked this one out again for the whatevereth time and I love it.  Maddie loves it too.

It's a short story about a day in the life of Dimity Duck.  Basically she wakes up, eats, plays with her frog friend, then gets tired and goes to bed.  Simple as that!

The illustrations are nice.  They are bright but still pretty soft I think.  I'm a sucker for a plain white background (it just makes the pictures and words stand out so clearly) and the book alternates between figures and text on white backgrounds then full illustrations.

But frankly what I love about this book are the words.  The rhythm of the words is musical, with rhymes to accent.  Really, the rhythm just makes me happy.  Also, since it's a day-in-the-life type story, it doesn't feel forced when Dimity goes to bed.  This one has the duck going to bed a little more slowly so I think it works as a plausible last book of the day without pigeon-holing itself awkwardly into the role.

If you have a 2-3 year old, I think this likely is a great book.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Book Review: "The Monster at the End of this Book"

"The Monster at the End of this Book" by the Sesame Street Industrial Complex.

This is not a book that I picked. This is definitely a selection by Hannah.  I think Maddie first brought it to me at the library where I read it to her.  Hannah later came over and I read it again to her.  She loved it.  For about a week she was reading this every other book.

When I first read it I tried a pseudo-Grover voice.  It's been a long time since I've heard Grover.  I think the voice helped.  There were two things that Hannah liked about the book: first; Grover speaks directly to the reader, "interacting" with the reader in response to turning the pages, i.e. asking the reader not to turn the page and then getting upset on the next page about having the page turned; second, Grover is the monster at the end of the book.  Once he discovers this he acts as if he weren't scared at all, but that the reading was.  Hannah thought this was funny.  I suppose I like that she likes it.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Two Book Reviews: Simms Taback's Big Book of Words and A Country Mouse in the Town House by Henrietta

Simms Taback's Big Book of Words
We've gotten this a few times from the library. This most recent time I checked it out because Maddie pulled it off the shelf herself. When the enthusiasm of one of our kids reaches that level I start to let my preferences subside a bit.

I'm not sure of Mr. Taback's credentials as an author, but I am not a fan of his illustration style for this type of book. He has a very bumpy style that typically lacks shading and has a two dimensional look. We've gotten a version of The Little Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly that he illustrated and I liked his style there more.

This is one of those books that has a picture and then the word for the picture. When making direct associations like that I guess I just think clearer, more accurate pictures (whether illustrations or actual photographs) are better for this type of book.

So Maddie and I are split on this one. She loves it. It was the first book we read this morning. I don't. It has at least 50 pages of clothing, food, animals and other things.

A Country Mouse in the Town House by Henrietta
I put the author's "handle" in the title, because I just don't know how to handle single-name authors. We've checked out this one at least once before, but I am quite sure it wasn't received so well the first time.

Maddie has enjoyed this one as well. It is a look-for-the-hidden-thing kind of book. On each page there is at least a country mouse and later on a town mouse is added. It took me a little while to see the line that explained to oddly places peas on all the pages. So in addition to finding the mouse or mice, we also hunt for 5 peas. We have found them all on most pages, but there are at least two scenes in which the three of us haven't managed yet. I guess we need to get Natalie's eyes involved and make it a full family effort.

Both Maddie and Hannah enjoy searching for and pointing out the mice. I think the peas have been good for Maddie as she starts learning to count. On the easy pages she can find them all, and I think they are spaced far enough apart that her counting is more accurate than when counting a group of things on a smaller page.

The text is fine, although the kids hardly seem to pay any attention to it. When we open the book they go straight into their hunting mode.

Sunday, October 25, 2009

Halloween Book Review: Room on the Broom

It's been a while since I last posted for several reasons, but I figured I needed to pull a bit of the blog's weight.

Room on the Broom (by Julia Donaldson with illustrations by Axel Scheffler) is a new book to me. This is a recent book, published this decade. If I recall correctly this was a gift to Hannah from a friend, Emma, and her parents.

We've made some efforts to keep holiday books aside in their off-seasons to that they'll "stay fresh," but this is one that has managed to stay on the shelves much longer.

This book is by far my favorite halloween book. It's written in a clear, consistent rhyme that moves along quickly and playfully. The verse is also very clear. I think that's part of why I like to read it to the kids. Some rhyming books stretch a bit too much or the meter isn't as obvious to me, so I don't approach them with the confidence this book gives.

The story involves a clumsy witch and four friends she meets along her way: a cat, a frog, a bird, and a dog. In the end, the animals work together to save the witch from a hungry dragon. If you are looking for a great halloween book for the youngsters, check this one out.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Review: Skippyjon Jones - Judy Schachner

This is a book that was new to me. It was a gift (I think a Christmas gift) to Hannah from one of her Grandmothers.

This book is "crazy loco," which normally doesn't hit the spot for me. But Hannah took to it quickly. It took me a few times through to make sure I got the story right.

Skippyjon Jones is an adventuresome Siamese cat. He has an extremely active imagination that comes into play quickly when he is sitting in his room having a "time-out" at his mother's insistence.

As he bounces on the bed he sees his reflection in the mirror, but it's not that of a Siamese cat. He becomes El Skippito Bandito, a sword-fighting chihuahua in old Mexico. He is quickly tapped by a band of other chihuahua's to battle a gigantic bee that has been taking their frijoles.

Soon after Hannah got it, she would call herself "Skippyjon Jones," Natalie was "Mama Junebug Jones," and I was Skippyjones's alter ego El Skippito Bandito. It's hard to not like a book when Hannah gets caught up in it like that. The name "Skippyjon Jones" is a gem on its own, very fun to say.

So if your kids like silly books, and since your kids are kids they probably do, it worth a look if you haven't seen it already. As a bonus to those in the Philly area, the author from this neck of the woods....not that that really makes any difference, but trivia will come in handy if you ever find yourself on Jeopardy!...

There was sequel which did not meet with the success of the original in the Meacham household.

Saturday, April 25, 2009

Two Books by Virginia Lee Burton

It's been a while since either of us has written about children's books. I'd like to mention two by one author. This nice young lady to the right is Virginia Lee Burton. She was born in Massachussets, the daughter of the first dean of MIT. According to the bio on Houghton Mifflin's website, she had a very nice childhood, filled with books that he father would read to her.

The two books I'll mention here are "The Little House" (1942) and "Mike Mulligan and His Steam Shovel" (1939) As usual, they are books I grew up with and enjoy passing along. The two to me have a thematic relation about the passage of time and the obsolescence of technologies that accompanies it.

"The Little House" is about, well, a little house. The house starts out away from the city, but the city grows out to it and up around it. Where it began as a quiet house, the city's noise, pollution, and skyline nearly ungulf it, until it is trucked off to live in the country again with a new coat of paint.

"Mike Mulligan" is about a steam-powered excavator, Mary Anne, and her operator, Mike Mulligan. They're put out of work by the new, generally better performing generation of diesel excavators. While other steam shovels are left to rust in heaps, Mike takes good care of Mary Anne. He finds work when he leave the big city to dig the basement of the new town hall in Popperville. In the end Mary Anne lived on as the furnace of the town hall.

To me, both books seem hostile to urban environments and both have a real anti-waste component. The house, rather than get torn down even when it's run down, is moved to a new site. The steam-shovel, a comparatively weaker technological platform, is put to new use on a different application. Neither is really what it used to be, but neither it tossed in the scrap-heap. I don't know that there was a strong environmental movement back when these books were written, so it seems likely that it is either an anti-waste perspective or she that objects were then more worthy of personal attachment.

I listened to a podcast about religion and consumption in which Juliet Schor (author of "Born to Buy", which I think I might have reviewed here) said that she thought our society needed to get more materialistic. By that she meant that we need to consider the things we buy more carefully, and after a purchase appreciate and care more for the things we have. When I hear the loud whirring of our 3rd DVD player in 6 years of marriage, I think she might be right. Hopefully the next one we buy will be so good we can name her "Mary Anne."

Friday, September 26, 2008

Review: Damages by Barry Werth.

For a while my little "Taylor is reading..." element on the right-hand side listed Free to Choose by Milton Friedman. I haven't touched that book since school started.

Damages by Barry Werth, was assigned as part of my reading for my torts class. It is subtitled "One Family's Legal Struggles in the World of Medicine." More than following the Sabia family, Werth follows a lawsuit from start to finish.

Donna Sabia gave birth to twin boys, Little Tony and Michael. Little Tony's apgar score was 1; Michael had been dead for a few days. Little Tony will (he's still alive) never learn to walk or talk. He can't eat or control his bodily functions.

A lawsuit was not on the Sabia family radar until Donna chanced to meet a woman who had herself sued a doctor for malpractice.

The book tells the tale from when Little Tony's parents meet until the lawsuit comes to an end. In some ways I thought the book was dry, almost sterile, while at the same time delving into situations and feelings that were any else. The view of the lawsuit is expansive, covering about a decade. You're taken along to the depositions of the Sabias, the doctor who delivered Tony, and to the search for expert witnesses that would back up the lawyers' theories. There are lawyers for the Sabias, the doctor, the doctor's insurance company, the hospital, and the hospital's insurance company. At the same time, Werth also presents a view on the struggles that Donna and Tony and their other kids face.

It's not always easy to know who to cheer for in the book. Nobody's portrayed as perfect, and most folks have some glaring faults. People have various personal motives. But such is life, and apparently such is the field of medical malpractice.

My professor assigned the book to give us a window into tort law (the kind of law that encompasses medical malpractice). He used to teach at UConn, and had various people from the book give presentations to his tort classes there. Using Damages was a very effective way to inject some "big picture" into our casebook reading.

If you have an interest in law and/or medicine, I recommend Damages.

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Two More Chillun's Books

Sometimes when Hannah and I go to the library, I do a bit of browsing. I should probably do it more often, but sometimes I bring a book of my own, in which case Hannah has to do the book finding.

A while ago I came across There's Always Room for One More by the Schuberts. While I don't mind the absence of illustrations in the books I read to myself, I really like great illustrations in the books I read to Hannah. The watercolors of the book are what made me pick it up. I'm a sucker for animals (and have indoctrinated Hannah to be so as well), so these soft, friendly creatures make me (I mean Hannah) feel all cozy-inside.

The plot is very simple, the book is quite brief. Beaver builds a raft so that all his pals can go for rides together. As his buddies pile on one by one, the raft sinks slowly. By balancing perfectly they can all stay afloat though. But as I'm sure you may have surmised, balancing perfectly is hard to do.

These two have written other books as well, at least some with the same character and in the same easy-going style.

Now onto the next book...

If, like so many of us, you want your toddler to know her name, age, and party affiliation before she scurries off to preschool, allow me to recommend Why Mommy is a Democrat and its cuddly companion, Why Daddy is a Democrat.

You may think kids aren't concerned with their party identity at such a tender age, but according to Kyleigh Gruhkle (age 5), you are wrong.

The book teaches Democratic principles such "fairness, tolerance, peace, equality, and concern for the well-being of others." These two books teach such Party principles as:

"Sometimes the earth feels a little sick. Democrats make it feel better again." (see the illustration here)

"Democrats make sure we are always safe, just like mommy does." (see the illustration here)

As we all know, if children aren't taught carefully when young they are likely to do dangerous things as teenagers. For example, some teenagers have been known to send text-messages when driving, or even experiment with drugs or the Republican party. Teaching your children when they are young may help them select friends carefully to avoid such troubles.

To some extent I think these books could be a little more effective. Perhaps yet another book is in order, like Why Mommy Would Never-Ever-Forever Be a Republican or Even Have Friends Who Might Be. This book could help children understand the Republican principles of unfairness, intolerance, war, inequality, and thorough lack of concern for the well-being of others. Some illustrations might be captioned:

"Sometimes the Earth feels good. Republicans make it feel sick again."

"Republicans make sure schools are filled with evil beauraucrats and terrible teachers." (see less effective illustration)

"Republicans want policemen and firefights to stop criminals and put out fires with nothing but their bare hands." (see less effective illustration)

The message of the book is very much needed at this moment in our great nation's history. At a time when our country is so divided by a political gulf, can we afford to let our children--our future--play near the edge? I think not.

T

Monday, June 16, 2008

The Revolution: A Manifesto

I guess the revolution really won't be fully televised. It might get a few minutes on TV, and it might get some coverage in the back of the newspaper.

This is my review of Ron Paul's The Revolution: A Manifesto. I voted for Rep. Paul in the Republican primary, and frankly I'm very likely to vote for him again in November.

The book is a simple, easy read. Paul talks about the current state of politics in America. He talks about the first century of foreign policy as well as the second century, which was very different. The concept of blowback in relation to more than just military actions but also military inactions (having hundreds of thousands of troops stationed all over the world) is explained. He also talks about it specifically in relation to 9/11, addressing the "why" question without settling for "they hate us for our freedoms" or "they hate us because we are immoral infidels."

He uses the simple illustration of sugar tariffs to introduce a chapter on economic freedom. Paul is a big proponent of free trade: free as in no government agreements required. In America since looting is allowed, every special interest tries as hard as it can to get its unfair share. Since you can, why not? People have come to think of redistribution of wealth in terms of Robin Hood. But in America the analogy breaks down. When you take from rightful owners and give to others you aren't helping, you're stealing. Intentions, however noble, don't alter the fact. As I'm sure everyone will agree, not everything the government does is legal.

As you may imagine, the Federal Reserve is called to task. It's interesting to think about in light of recent troubles. In part the Fed's job was to prevent things like the housing bubble. And let's just consider for a bit. If the Fed hadn't cut rates so much artificially than how many people would have had such an easy time getting homes that they couldn't afford? Isn't it nice that the Fed (an unelected body intended to be non-partisan) has so much control. So the Fed is supposed to prevent inflation while it's at it, but just ask your parents how much their first car cost. I'm afraid the Fed hasn't managed in that spot either. Why not have the market set rates?

I talked with my two of my brothers about these issues and others raised in the book this past weekend. One brother kept insisting that people don't really want to be free and responsible for themselves. And I think there are definitely some people that fit that bill. But I think the concept really appeals to folks. It certainly appealed to Franklin, Washington, Henry, Jefferson, Madison, Adams.

Consider this simple question: if the government were to eliminate all its welfare programs (social security, medicare, medicaid, etc.), would you be more or less likely to donate your time and money to your fellow man? We often forget that people got along without massive government looting for a long time. Once upon a time, doctors and lawyers (and most other professions) donated time and skill. Once upon a time less than 50 years ago, all attorneys were basically "on-call" to defend people that couldn't afford a lawyer. I guess people just differ on what it would be like to do it again. My vote's for "let's do it." Do you think education would really be worse if states could do their own thing and not have to spend education dollars supporting a federal bureaucracy on top of it all?

Lately we've heard numerous cries for government to "fix" the cost of gas. What else do we want government to fix for us? Government "fixes" like social security are problems. Please check this message from the Social Security and Medicare Board of Trustees. Way to go government! Let's see what else can we get you to fix for us, it's so much easier to just sit on our duffs.

Some people don't care much for Ron Paul, because of his stance on drugs. Ever wonder why there had to be an amendment to the Consistitution to make alcohol illegal (and to make it legal again), but we now have lots of drugs that are illegal with no such "laborious" efforts? I'm ready to try something new. I haven't heard of a lot of success in the "war on drugs." Einstein's definition of insanity keeps coming to mind.

I'm sure most of you already have your minds set on Obama or McCain. I'm sure both of them have great plans for balancing the budget while expanding spending on welfare (Obama) or "defense" spending (McCain). Obama had a Bilderberger picking his VP, obviously the traditional Washington connections can wrap him up just as easily as the next guy. I am not sure on the war in Iraq, it's hard for me to think we should just say "Sorry we wrecked your country...Best of luck with that!" But history will want to repeat itself, and I don't trust Obama or McCain to keep the U.S. out of the next version. Obama's pull-out promise will likely fade completely once he's in. A vote for either of them is a vote to continue policies that hurt our nation and will make things harder for your children.

During Ralph Nader's bid for the presidency in 2000 (the one where he was considered inconsequential and thus not invited to debates and later blamed for Gore's loss) Michael Moore said something I completely agree with. "If you are voting for the lesser of two evils, you are still voting for evil." (Just for your info, Mr. Moore changed his tune completely for the 2004 election.)

I highly (and seriously) recommend The Revolution.

T

P.S. I did really appreciate Pell grants...

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Blindness

So this post is a bit review, a bit commentary, and a bit -- dare I say it? -- Hollywood current events.

I was snooping around on Apple's trailer website, something I do every now and again to see what movies I will plan on getting from NetFlix, and I saw a movie called Blindness. I read a book by the same name a few years ago and wondered it the same story. Turns out it is.

After I came back from São Paulo, my brother gave me a book by José Saramago, a Portuguese author. I started reading The Gospel According to Jesus Christ, but eventually quit as my orthodoxy made it very unappealing. (Maybe it's a good book, who knows?) I tried another one, Todos os Nomes (All the Names), this time in Portuguese. I should give it another whirl, because I didn't make it through that one either. Maybe my fluency wasn't good enough. One thing to note about Mr. Saramago's writing: there are no quotation marks. There's still dialog, but you basically have to read the speaker into it. Don't worry, you get used to it that, and it keeps you on your toes looking for the "voice" of the speaker. I suppose that "technique" fits this story very well.

Eventually I bought a copy of Blindness I happened to spy during a sale at the local library. I made it all the way through and "liked" the book. I don't mean I found it "fun". It's not at all that kind of book. I generally dislike the word "gritty", perhaps because I think it's bandied about trying to excuse things shouldn't be excused, but it fits here well. I've recommended the book to only one person who actually started reading it, and last I heard she set it aside as too much of a downer.

I think I was lucky to know nothing about the plot of the book when I picked it up, and I'd like to preserve that for folks that want to give it a go in like manner. Let me just say there are obvious reasons it was titled Blindness. The book presents a grim view of human behavior, but I found myself hoping he (Saramago) was wrong, which means I have some real fears he may not be. It makes me question myself and how deep whatever goodness is in me really runs. There are rays of hope and goodness, make no mistake, but they are rays breaking through an otherwise very overcast sky.

I guess I have mixed feelings about the movie. The brief description I read said it was a "psychological thriller". I didn't think of the book as a "thriller", but it did seem plenty psychological. Without at least one significant cut, I think I can assume movie will be rated R, which means I won't ever have a decent opinion of the movie. Even if it's not, I'm not sure if I'll see it. If they do a good job it will be terrible, and if they do a bad job... I suspect it will be one of the much-better-book-than-movie stories.

Tuesday, March 25, 2008

Review: Unspun

I can't remember how I first came across this book. I'm not sure whether I came across it or FactCheck.org (a website run by the authors and associated with the Annenberg Public Policy Center at the University of Pennsylvania) first.

Well, the subtitle summarizes well the point of the book: how do you sort out the truth from the lies? The website's focus seems to be on political lies, but the book's is more general.

Let's face it, getting the facts straight from the news isn't even cakewalk. Maybe things used to be different, but maybe not. That's actually they way they intro the book. A brief bit about the original snake-oil and then a bit about modern snake-oil. The surprise: modern snake-oil is actually more expensive.

They go on the preach a healthy skepticism, but also against cynicism. They site a few big factual distortions, such as one I thought was fact. The Bush Administration allowed a special flight for relatives of Osama bin Laden to leave the country during the ban on all air travel following September 11th. Where did the fact originate? It was first implied by Michael Moore in
Fahrenheit 9/11. What made the authors, who originally believed it, change their minds (and mine)? The nonpartisan 9/11 Comission's famous report, who apparently thought this rumor was bad enough they needed to set the facts straight. The special chartered flight was after the ban, and almost all those on it were interviewed before leaving by the FBI.

It's odd to think that so many people really, really want to deceive you. But for money, or votes, or power people get seriously crazy. The authors then go on to describe a bit about how they check the facts for FactCheck.org, giving some good sources of reliable, non-partisan (and sometimes partisan) information.

Allow me to conclude with a recent addition to FactCheck.org about Hillary Clinton's now-debated role in SCHIP. I thought this one was really illustrative of what I perceive as politics-as-usual today. In a recent Boston Globe article, Hillary Clinton's previously recognized role in the SCHIP program was called into question. Here's a quote from the article:

Asked whether Clinton was exaggerating her role in creating SCHIP, [Senator "Ted"] Kennedy, stopped in the hallway as he was entering the chamber to vote, half-shrugged.

"Facts are stubborn things," he said, declining to criticize Clinton directly. "I think we ought to stay with the facts."

Here's where FactCheck.org helps things get interesting: Sen. Kennedy used to sing a very different tune.

From the Washington Times, Aug. 6, 1997: One of the co-authors of the plan, Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, Massachusetts Democrat, credited Mrs. Clinton for her "invaluable help, both in the fashioning and the shaping of the program."

From an AP/Boston Globe story dated Oct. 6, 2007: Sen. Kennedy said "The children's health program wouldn't be in existence today if we didn't have Hillary pushing for it from the other end of Pennsylvania Avenue."

So, what what changed in between October 2007 and March 2008? Senator Kennedy endorsed Barack Obama! I wonder why the American public doesn't heartily approve of politics-as-usual...

The book was good, informative, and motivational. You need to have a little confidence that you can sort out truth from lies in order to even want to try, and I think this book helped out in that regard. It's also short and a light read. It served well as my "intermission" for another book.

Thursday, March 6, 2008

Book of the Week: The Snowy Day by Ezra Jack Keats

It's important to note that while "Book of the Week" may imply a continuity of books corresponding to the continuity of weeks, this just hasn't happened, and it won't. So please accept our sporadic efforts.

So here's another one from my childhood that's finding its way into Hannah's. This is a simpler one than Liza Lou, so Hannah can follow the story much more easily.

Well, as the name suggests, the book is about a snowy day; a day spent playing in the snow. Peter wakes up in the morning, looking out of the window of his apartment, sees snow everywhere. He makes tracks, a snowman, and snow angels, before he comes home to take a nice warm bath. It's certainly not a "high octane" book, but that's part of what makes it so good. You know how the snow makes things quieter? That's sort of the way I think about this book. It's fun, but pretty calm, go-at-your-own-snailish-pace fun. Grade A, mother-approved kind of fun.

The illustrations are great, I prefer them to Keats later work (like Louie, another childhood favorite), because the lines are clearer. Textures are rich, but they are generally not of the brush-stroke variety like Eric Carle. Some of them look fabric or wallpaper-like.

Natalie's read this several times to Hannah already, but my first time was today. It's a good book for us, because it's one of the very few (I can't think of any others), where the main character lives in an apartment. It received a Caldecott Medal, the most prestigious prize for a children's book.

Hurry and check it out before Old Man Winter melts into spring.

Saturday, December 1, 2007

Review: Standardized Childhood

A few months ago, I was visiting with my brother and his family in Tulsa. A bit before dinner I was reading in the (or least a) local paper when I saw a review for a book called "Standardized Childhood". I then noticed the alluring subtitle "The Political and Cultural Struggle Over Early Education". Naturally I was intrigued. I pointed it out to my mom, a special education preschool teacher, or as she would probably prefer, an early childhood special education teacher. I figured she'd be more interested than I was. She planned on buying it, and I was lucky enough to find it at the library.

With Hannah at 2.5 and another girl due (this month!), I decided it would be a worthwhile read for me. It's taken quite a while to finish up (and I actually skipped a whole chapter on latino kids), but it was actually pretty interesting. I won't actually give a real review here, but hopefully I can whet some appetites.

Maybe in some of the states in which you all live you've been aware of some initiatives that promote "preschool for all", in effort to help kids prepare for our highly competitive global economy, and to close achievement gaps, raise 1st grade test scores, etc.

The author, Bruce Fuller, a sociologist at Berkeley, begins pointing out that tacking kindergarten onto public schools was supposed to do exactly that, but it didn't. That alone should make you suspicious about preschool's ability to do it. There are chapters addressing UPK (universal pre-kindergarten) initiatives in Oklahoma and California. These chapters were eye-opening in demonstrating who gets these things rolling, people like Rob Reiner (the director of The Princess Bride), some heir to the Gap fortune, and rich oil fellows in OK. In general, the movements aren't started by parents or by educators. The politics behind the systems and the significant differences in their final implementations was interesting since the stories are so distinct.

The book helped me to understand the claims, and the background for the claims, made by people trying to push these systems. For instance the claim that "X amount of brain development occurs between 1 and 3 years of age" does not mean that "X amount of mental or cognitive development occurs" between those times. But isn't that much more important than simple increase in mass?

Fuller offers a summary of early childhood education studies and helps explain what has and has not been shown, in light of the claims currently being made. For instance the claim that making all kids go to preschool will (1) increase test scores and (2) close achievement gaps is either contradictory or one must conclude that preschool doesn't help everyone equally (and hence, why should tax payers foot the bill for for everyone?).

For most kids, especially middle-class kids, the beneficial effects of preschool fade with time, even for very high quality preschools. Cognitive gains taper off after about 15 hours per week, but for apparently everyone but latino kids, spending more time can create a slowdown in social-emotional development. He talks quite a bit about the differences between cultures in how children are raised, and how UPK implementations often try to find a "one, best system" for preschoolers. One thing worth noting is that legislative initiatives rarely try to create a high quality programs (the one's which generate the encouraging results). They are more often geared to increasing pre-math and pre-reading skills than the things that parents express the most concern about (regarding preschool-aged kids): social and emotional development.

The author isn't at all against taxpayer funded preschooling, but his bias is definitely against strict "skilling" approaches to preschool. He admits,"I do worry that the push to universalize and standardize preschooling in America will disempower parents from the most essential human task of all: raising young children."

If you have interest in the education of young children or education policy, I'd definitely recommend it. Parts of it were definitely dry and tedious for a layperson like me, but other parts had great information delivered with some actual intrigue (relatively). ;-)

[Don't worry. I'm not expecting a lot of traffic in the comments section for this post.]