
A few months ago, I was visiting with my brother and his family in Tulsa. A bit before dinner I was reading in the (or least
a) local paper when I saw a review for a book called "Standardized Childhood". I then noticed the alluring subtitle "The Political and Cultural Struggle Over Early Education". Naturally I was intrigued. I pointed it out to my mom, a special education preschool teacher, or as she would probably prefer, an early childhood special education teacher. I figured she'd be more interested than I was. She planned on buying it, and I was lucky enough to find it at the library.
With Hannah at 2.5 and another girl due (this month!), I decided it would be a worthwhile read for me. It's taken quite a while to finish up (and I actually skipped a whole chapter on latino kids), but it was actually pretty interesting. I won't actually give a real review here, but hopefully I can whet some appetites.
Maybe in some of the states in which you all live you've been aware of some initiatives that promote "preschool for all", in effort to help kids prepare for our highly competitive global economy, and to close achievement gaps, raise 1st grade test scores, etc.
The author, Bruce Fuller, a sociologist at Berkeley, begins pointing out that tacking kindergarten onto public schools was supposed to do exactly that, but it didn't. That alone should make you suspicious about preschool's ability to do it. There are chapters addressing UPK (universal pre-kindergarten) initiatives in Oklahoma and California. These chapters were eye-opening in demonstrating who gets these things rolling, people like Rob Reiner (the director of The Princess Bride), some heir to the Gap fortune, and rich oil fellows in OK. In general, the movements aren't started by parents or by educators. The politics behind the systems and the significant differences in their final implementations was interesting since the stories are so distinct.
The book helped me to understand the claims, and the background for the claims, made by people trying to push these systems. For instance the claim that "X amount of brain development occurs between 1 and 3 years of age" does not mean that "X amount of mental or cognitive development occurs" between those times. But isn't that much more important than simple increase in mass?
Fuller offers a summary of early childhood education studies and helps explain what has and has not been shown, in light of the claims currently being made. For instance the claim that making all kids go to preschool will (1) increase test scores and (2) close achievement gaps is either contradictory or one must conclude that preschool doesn't help everyone equally (and hence, why should tax payers foot the bill for for everyone?).
For most kids, especially middle-class kids, the beneficial effects of preschool fade with time, even for very high quality preschools. Cognitive gains taper off after about 15 hours per week, but for apparently everyone but latino kids, spending more time can create a slowdown in social-emotional development. He talks quite a bit about the differences between cultures in how children are raised, and how UPK implementations often try to find a "one, best system" for preschoolers. One thing worth noting is that legislative initiatives rarely try to create a high quality programs (the one's which generate the encouraging results). They are more often geared to increasing pre-math and pre-reading skills than the things that parents express the most concern about (regarding preschool-aged kids): social and emotional development.
The author isn't at all against taxpayer funded preschooling, but his bias is definitely against strict "skilling" approaches to preschool. He admits,"I do worry that the push to universalize and standardize preschooling in America will disempower parents from the most essential human task of all: raising young children."
If you have interest in the education of young children or education policy, I'd definitely recommend it. Parts of it were definitely dry and tedious for a layperson like me, but other parts had great information delivered with some actual intrigue (relatively). ;-)
[Don't worry. I'm not expecting a lot of traffic in the comments section for this post.]