Showing posts with label Commentary. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commentary. Show all posts

Sunday, December 11, 2011

Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood

I've got a reason to root for Rick Santorum. In 2003, Rick Santorum and Arlen Spector sponsored a Senate Resolution honoring Fred McFeely Rogers, their fellow Pennsylvanian.


Mr. Rogers gave testimony in Sony Corp. of America v. Universal City Studios, Inc. about whether recording videos at home on Betamax and helped the court decide that "time-shifting" of TV shows was a lawful use of copyrighted TV shows and movies.


Because of that I've wondered why old episodes of Mr. Rogers' weren't online for free.  The girls had seen clips from the show on the PBS site about making crayons and shoes. Up until recently I don't think any full episodes were available, but I discovered that PBS had about 30 full length episodes up for streaming.  


The other night, I was trying to keep the kids settled down and at 8:30 I put on their first episode of Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood.  I was a bit worried about getting them settled down afterwards, but it wasn't an issue.


I could hear it playing, and the first thing I noticed was that it was so calm.  The pace and the atmosphere is very different from any modern shows.  A half-hour later as the kids were very cooperatively laying down to bed, Hannah said "I like Mr. Rogers because he takes us to new places, introduces us to new people, and takes us to the land of make-believe."  


That sums it up.  Mr. Rogers said "I went into television because I hated it so, and I thought there was some way of using this fabulous instrument to be of nurture to those who would watch and listen."  He succeeded in a way no modern TV has even tried.  He said, “The whole idea, is to look at the television camera and present as much love as you possibly could to a person who might feel that he or she needs it.”  Let's see a computer-animated, academic-readiness focused program to do!



Saturday, June 11, 2011

Review: "Spoilt Rotten: The Toxic Cult of Sentimentality" by Theodore Dalrymple

Sentimentality does no harm when it is confined to the private sphere....But as the wellspring of public policy, or of public reaction to events or social problems, it is as disastrous as it is prevalent.

Theodore Dalrymple, an Englishman, spent the bulk of his career as a psychiatrist/prison doctor for many years and has been writing for quite a while as well.  His work gives an interesting perspective to this book, and I suspect his other writing as well.

First, Dalrymple is not saying that emotions are bad.  In fact he says emotions are "necessary to all cognitive activity and rational thought.  Without an emotional stance to the world, one would do nothing, think nothing and seek nothing."

But the book's premise is that we've let emotion run amok.  More precisely, we've let public expressions of emotions run amok.  "It is no longer enough to shed a tear in private over the death of Little Nell; it is necessary to do so, or the modern equivalent, in full public view.... In such a world, what is done or happens in private is not done or has not happened at all, at least not in the fullest sense."  For Facebook users, think about how many times you've been "asked" to prove your support for child-abuse victims, Jesus, or America by reposting.

Friday, May 6, 2011

Review: "I Am a Promise: The Children of Stanton Elementary School"

We got I Am a Promise: The Children of Stanton Elementary School (1993) on a whim at the library.  We both saw Waiting for Superman a while ago and I watched The Lottery on Hulu before that.  I  think education policy is very interesting.  I am a real believer in education as a key to social-mobility.  I also am glad I could just attend my neighborhood schools my whole life.

However, I don't think education (at least the in-school kind) is the key to social-mobility.  Some of this is because, while I frankly admire schooler reformers like Geoffrey Canada, the KIPP guys, and Michelle Rhee who make waves in their own ways, none of them has the full solution.  Well, Canada seems closer in some ways as I'll explain.

If you haven't seen Waiting for Superman (or The Cartel or The Lottery, or some other one) let me sum up.  The shows follow the stories of a few bright kids whose parent are desperately trying to get them into a better school.  We feel sad when it doesn't happen, we feel happy when it does.  In the meantime we are told that teachers' unions are the big baddy that's crushing American education.  Don't get me wrong, I buy the "teachers' unions are not serving children" bit hook-line-and-sinker.  But there are limits to the reforms that none of those shows seem to acknowledge, that few "reformers" seem to want to acknowledge.  If you want to get an idea of how those limits might play out, watch I Am a Promise.  I think its probably worth more of your time than Waiting for Superman.

I Am a Promise is about the people at one school in North Philly.  The neighborhood around the school is rife with poverty of all kinds.  The area is blighted and overrun with crime of various kinds.  The families struggle to stay together and keep it together.  We meet some of the kids at the school, but they aren't the "stars" like in the reform movie, they are kids.  The principal is there at 6:00AM, who knows when she leaves at night, and she's in on weekends as well.  Most of the kids have presumably well-intentioned, but seemingly inept, parents.  Some parents are drug-addicts.  The teachers talk to the kids about what to do if a person with a gun comes into their house.  There are a lot of special-ed kids, but its clear that a lot of them are in there for behavioral issues, not real mental delays.

Sunday, October 17, 2010

Debt and Charitable Giving: Pay thy debt, and give?

I was talking with a friend at school and he posed what I think is an interesting question: should people in debt give money to charities?  I don't think he was sure of his opinion, but one of the things he mentioned was that if those in debt didn't give it might remind those who aren't in debt of their responsibilities.  We talked about how strange it is to give a panhandler money when if you looked at total capital assets the panhandler is much better off.  I could be wrong, but I am pretty soon most panhandlers' balance sheets look much better than mine.  This may say more about the limitations of balance sheets to capture reality than anything, but still we've got a "healthy" amount of student debt.  I also wonder if giving money while in debt is a kind of hypocrisy: acting like you have a surplus of wealth. 

Maybe that's a possible decision criterion: when you have a net surplus of wealth, give; when you have a net surplus of debt, don't give.  Clearly having some debt you are managing well is very different from having more liabilities than assets.  But I don't think a line can be safely drawn there as an absolute.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

This is Achievement's Plan?

I've seen this in the newspaper for a few weeks now, and every time I chuckle a bit.  I suppose they don't say it's a "great" plan.  Maybe I'll feel better when we try to get a home loan in a few years.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

The Karate Kid Fantasy

This blog post is brought to you by Daniel Willingham and the new Karate Kid movie.

Some time last week I came across a book called "Why Don't Students Like School?"  I'd like to read it some day.  I did some digging on the author, Daniel Willingham, a cognitive scientist at the University of Virginia.  I found an "EconTalk" podcast that was an interview with him.  The host started out mentioning one of the points of the book: thinking is hard, so we often try not to do it.

The thought came to my mind again while I was on an airplane heading to San Jose, CA for a job interview, and the new version of The Karate Kid came on as the in-flight movie.  I was reading a book but glanced up enough to follow the story, which didn't take much.  Basically the story has been unchanged, except the "Kid" movies to China instead of California.

Coupling the thought "thinking is hard" with the Karate Kid I came up with the realization that the story of The Karate Kid is one about the fantasy of the perfect teacher.

Just think about it for a second.  Johnny (the bad guy in the original Karate Kid) had probably been training for years.  Daniel Larusso on the other hand... How many solid weeks of hard work would you guess went into his success?  But Daniel-san, had the perfect teacher.  Did he work hard from start to finish?  Nope.  He didn't, but at some point Mr. Miyagi showed him how much he had begrudgingly, half-heartedly, unknowingly learned.  We were all very impressed.  And then I think he might have put in some effort.

I think there are plenty of times in my life when I have waited for a perfect teacher, someone to inspire me to take on the heavy lifting of serious thought, one that could (1) make me want to work hard even when I didn't want to work hard (hey, if you can't pull off contradictions, it must be your fault!) and (2) make even my mediocre efforts produce Champion-level gains.  You can imagine how well things work out when I decide to wait.

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

Book Review: "The Monster at the End of this Book"

"The Monster at the End of this Book" by the Sesame Street Industrial Complex.

This is not a book that I picked. This is definitely a selection by Hannah.  I think Maddie first brought it to me at the library where I read it to her.  Hannah later came over and I read it again to her.  She loved it.  For about a week she was reading this every other book.

When I first read it I tried a pseudo-Grover voice.  It's been a long time since I've heard Grover.  I think the voice helped.  There were two things that Hannah liked about the book: first; Grover speaks directly to the reader, "interacting" with the reader in response to turning the pages, i.e. asking the reader not to turn the page and then getting upset on the next page about having the page turned; second, Grover is the monster at the end of the book.  Once he discovers this he acts as if he weren't scared at all, but that the reading was.  Hannah thought this was funny.  I suppose I like that she likes it.

Wednesday, December 30, 2009

Kids and TV

This semester I had a professor that got off on interesting, related tangents every now and again. The class was Internet Law and there was some discussion of the regulatory frameworks of broadcast and cable television. At some point he mentioned his (and his wife's) approach to television with their kids: two hours a week. That might have been total screen time, so computer and television time. This professor also mentioned that his kids didn't have a gaming system, would never be allowed to have TV's or computers in their rooms, and couldn't see PG-13 movies until they are 13.

It made me think about our approach to TV with Hannah and Maddie. One thing that has occurred to me is that Maddie, having an older sister, is going to see more television that Hannah did at that age. I think we kept Hannah's time down pretty well for her first 18 months to two years.

As most folks know, the American Academy of Pediatricians recommends that children under two watch absolutely no television or videos. I don't know many parents (if I know any) that follow that guideline. We dutifully follow health advice and buy hand-sanitizer buy the gallon, but this recommendation basically gets laughed off as impractical. Or we simply don't believe it. After all kids don't get running noses or fevers from watching TV. Anything adverse is internal, far more subtle. So following that kind of recommendation requires a different level of faith in pediatricians.

More faith than we have, apparently. We own several Kipper videos, one Spot video, Baby Mozart, a few Veggie Tales videos, and a couple others. We also often check out Little Einstein movies, Hannah had a huge Thomas phase that has now been in remission for a little while, and Maddie has chosen Dora (my arch-nemesis) a couple of times. Hannah used to watch a couple of shows on PBS, but the kids almost never ask to watch regular shows, just videos. The kids watch Nature with me on Sundays, or at least the first twenty minutes and then come in and out until the end. I love it, and sometimes the kids really like it too. When we have a video I try to skip the commercials for other videos, that eases my guilty conscience a little. While the quality of PBS shows leaves much to be desired, at least the kids don't see commercials.

I don't think the kids watch a ton of television, but they are definitely over the two hours a week...at least it's not an order of magnitude, right? It's just so easy to plug the kids into the TV if you need to get something done. And I think that's why most of us do it. If I remember correctly, I had a post about the Baby Einstein refund. I can't imagine that many folks think any videos are really educational (although that is the claim being made), so maybe it's parental laziness on our part or again that lack of faith in the AAP's for things that don't have symptoms.

Natalie and I have tried watching three Disney length features: Peter Pan, Cinderella, and the Fox and the Hound. Hannah's kind of a sensitive soul. So Peter Pan and the Fox and the Hound were too violent for her. We finished them at her request, but she was well snuggled for the intense parts. Cinderella was too adult for her. Ever tried explaining a wicked step-mother to a four year old? It's interesting to note that Maddie doesn't get scared during the parts when Hannah does. I would guess that's because Maddie doesn't understand enough to know the parts are scary (involving an imminent threat to a human life), while Hannah does. So, it's clear the stories are far over her head, so I think we can hold off a while longer until she can really enjoy them.

Media is one of my biggest sources of anxiety as a parent and I'm realizing that the more mixed in age our kids get as our family grows the more thoughtful I'll need to be about it. If you have any comments, fire away.

[While I was writing this Maddie asked to watch a Kipper video and a Noah's Ark video, and grabbed a DVD case and said,"I want to watch right now." Luckily I managed to get her to take a nap. Maybe staring at a screen to write a blog post isn't setting a great example...]

Sunday, June 21, 2009

Compensation and Societal Value(s)



I saw a link on the New York Times yesterday, and it got me thinking. It was for a list of the highest compensation packages for the CEO's of publicly-trade companies. I did a bit of googling on compensation for other folks, like athletes and entertainers. Take a look at the table I made and see what you think.

The sources I used are: [1], [2], and [3]. I am sure that the methodologies are different for all these sources. I have seen a list on Forbes of CEO compensation that was very different (much higher) from that of the Times. The different I think was caused by accounting of stocks and options, which is usually a larger portion of CEO compensation. Tiger Woods was on the athlete list and the celebrity list and I think the discrepancy between the lists is useful information.

The salaries are effectively set by different groups. CEO pay is determined by shareholders or at least with the shareholders' interests in mind. Athlete and celebrity pay is set by larger groups of Americans and so could be considered more representative of "societal" values.

Which group has more societal value? Meaning which has the most impact on us all? My vote is for CEO's, far behind come the celebrities, then the athletes. I think this is interesting in light of the efforts of the Obama administration and the wishes of Congress to exercise punitive control over compensation in firms receiving bailout money.

Monday, January 5, 2009

Wants and Needs


Caution: This post is heavy on the rambling. You may want to skip it, but you probably don't need to.

In my previous post I wrote that Natalie and I "know pretty well the difference between wants and needs." Natalie and I got to talking a bit on Sunday, and I realized we really don't know the difference, and I'm not sure if we really know a difference.

Here is the dictionary breakdown:
Need - (I'll use the definition of necessity) - an indispensable thing
Want - a desire for something

So needs are things without which we'll die? How quickly does the lack of it kill us? Is the need for air equal to the need for calcium? In one way yes, in another way no. The need to consume air is more pressing, but if you removed all the calcium (with a magical calcium-remover wand) from your body you would die more quickly than from the lack of air, right? These two definitions aren't separating, all needs can be wants. One thing I think is true: you don't have to want what you need.

Wikipedia has an entry on "fundamental human needs" according the a professor named Manfred Max-Neef. He disregarded Maslow's hierarchy of needs, which may be reasonable but only to a point. I think everyone would rate "subsistence" needs above "leisure" needs if put in a situation where a choice between them was required.

So let's allow that there are needs which are not subsistence and which are long-term. Here's where Natalie and I got a little lost. Are everyone's needs the same? Are one man's needs another man's wants? Are needs subjective? For example, if I genuinely believe I need a "new Rickenbacker guitar, two Fender Bassmans, a Chuck Berry song book, and a xylophone", does that mean I really need them?

Part of the conversation was about what we can or should ask God for. In 1987, President Hunter said,"There is a tendency for man to put himself in the center of the universe and expect others to conform to his wants and needs and desires. Yet nature does not honor that erroneous assumption. The central role in life belongs to God. Instead of asking him to do our bidding, we should seek into bring ourselves in harmony with his will..." We concluded that asking for needs is Kosher, but asking for wants was tricky. Alma 29:4 says that God "grants unto men according to their desire", which seems promising, but the rest of the verse makes it clear that he's not talking about stuff-wants.

When we were preparing to move to the Philly area, Natalie and I (I'm pretty sure I helped out with this) prayed that we could find a suitable place with a washer and dryer. This was important to Natalie. I don't have a good quote or scripture reference to justify it, but I think this is okay. It's not exactly riches, but at the same time the vast majority of the world doesn't have a washer and dryer. In the U.S. it's likely a different story. So are our desires relative? God will approve of our desire for a washer and dryer, but not if a peasant in Bangladesh asks for them because for the peasant it would be an outrageous luxury? Or is it that we are more easily able to exercise faith in our prayers for such things because they are somehow more like necessities in our country? "There, there, little luxury, don't you cry. You'll be a necessity by and by."* This introduces the subjective element.

One of my favorite daydreams (I enjoy daydreaming a whole lot more than planning) is of building my own (sorry, Natalie, someday it will be our own, but for now it's still mine). I don't want it to be huge, but I do want it to be very nice. I have no plans to make it into a hangout for the young men and young women of whatever ward it's in. I just want to live in a house that I think is unique and beautiful. Am I supposed to think that God really cares? We all seem to think God cares about literally everything we care about. That's usually put in terms of derivative interests - God loves me, I love the zoo, so God loves the zoo. If God really does care about everything derivatively, then it seems he should care proportionally. If I merely like the zoo, he merely likes the zoo. If I really, really want a new MacBook, he really, really wants me to have a new MacBook.

If that were the case, is it really unfair? The person will vary strong material wants (or the person who makes little attempt to distinguish between wants and needs) will be given much more than the person with weak material wants. Maybe such a system is completely fair. But then what of people who are naturally content? What of the people who try hard to be content? How are they rewarded?

Maybe that's where I fall off the rails. Thinking in terms of rewards, more specifically of material things being equal to rewards. Brigham Young equated riches with trials. "The worst fear that I have about [members of this Church] is that they will get rich in this country, forget God and his people, wax fat, and kick themselves out of the Church and go to hell. This people will stand mobbing, robbing, poverty, and all manner of persecution, and be true. But my greater fear for them is that they cannot stand wealth; and yet they have to be tried with riches." The less frequently cited part of that quote caught my eye.

When looking at the needs and wants of other folks, I could be looking to see if those are "right or wrong." I'm sure I do that. But I also wonder when I see folks that want more than I do, whether they are right to want more and to ask God for it, and my lack of wanting is effectively a lack of faith in God's willingness to grant according to my desires.

If you've read (or skimmed) to this point and you want to comment I'd appreciate your thoughts on a few questions. Do you ask God for things that you know are material wants and not needs? On what do you base your requests? Do you think God cares in proportion to how much you care? Do you think that's just? Can you think of an adequate test to determine the difference between a want and a need?

Wednesday, November 26, 2008

Slowing down the bursting of a bubble

Maybe it's just me, but the economic news has taken a turn for the worse. Either that or the amount of air time dedicated to it has filled the void of left by election season coverage.

The other night on the News Hour there was a story about the more recent moves of the government to prevent "disaster." I think I am becoming more convinced that things could get very bad indeed. One of the reasons why I think that is that I see the government's attempts to "restore" the economy not to correct it. It seems the goal is to turn the clock back to right before the bubble ended and then freeze it there.

In a clip Henry Paulson said, "Millions of Americans cannot find affordable financing for their basic credit needs. And credit card rates are climbing, making it more expensive for families to finance everyday purchases. This lack of affordable consumer credit undermines consumer spending and, as a result, weakens our economy."

That caught my ear. What are "basic credit needs"? I understand everyone needs credit for their house, and most people purchase cars in a way that necessitates credit. But that's it, right? That is not what Paulson thinks. "Consumer spending" encompasses much more than a house and a car, but he thinks the lack of credit available for those other "needs" weakens our economy. It seems to me the over availability of credit for those things is really what got us here. A strong economy apparently doesn't mean people can afford things, but that they can borrow money for things they can't afford. They can "finance" their everyday purchases, not pay for them.

In the segment a Harvard professor, and former IMF chief economist, Kenneth Rogoff said, "Well, the whole financial system's still imploding, and it's really on life support, and we're seeing the Fed have to step in to do basic functions for this financial system. They're giving money to the banks, but the banks aren't really actively lending, so they're having to get out and support the credit markets tremendously."

Banks make money by lending, as far as I know that's the only way they make money. Why would banks not want to make money? Why would they just keep the money the Fed is sending their way? For the exact same reason that lots of folks didn't "properly use" their stimulus checks (and why future "economic stimulus" may not be in check-to-taxpayer form): to pay off debt and/or to save. Banks have to have such "debt" to make money, but they get to call it leverage. Leverage is a ratio of the total money loaned out to the total deposits.

The Economist said, "[The current economic crisis is] a radical reassessment of what constitutes acceptable levels of capital, leverage and interest rates is underway. Those financial institutions that have not failed are intent on reducing leverage—their volume of loans for each dollar of capital. The Fed has no hope of stopping this process; it is merely trying to slow it down by providing a home for the assets that the financial sector is shedding."

So consumers and banks are doing the same thing, trying to correct a real problem. Consumers with too much debt are in a precarious position, banks with too much leverage (or maybe the phrase is "too little"?) are too. It seems to me like the proposed solution to fix the economic crisis is for banks and consumers to forget reality and do exactly what they shouldn't. This is some kind of logic puzzle in which if every individual does what is right for himself, everyone will get hurt. Conversely, if every individual jeopardizes himself, we'll all be okay.

I have a hard time comforting myself with that. Partially because I think that position is aimed at restoring the bubble. But since bubbles are by definition unsustainable, trying to restore one is absurd. Restore it so it can burst again? Housing prices needed to fall, they were simply overvalued, the supply overdeveloped.

So how do you slow down the bursting of a bubble? I realize now how good the "bubble" metaphor is. Bubbles have a pretty, iridescent surface with nothing of substance on the inside. And they don't unravel, they burst. I don't know that government shouldn't try to ease the transition, but I am not convinced the transition can really be eased. If we restore the bubble, it will certainly burst again later. Maybe the government doesn't need to start harping on saving this instant, but at least they should stop telling us all that our patriotic duty is to get into debt.

Sunday, November 2, 2008

California's Proposition 8

A friend of mine recently emailed me about Proposition 8, in California. It was the second email I received on the issue, so I decided that despite being a long, long way from Crazy Cali, I would look into it. I looked in the California Voter Information Guide.

Proposition 8 inserts the following words into California's state constitution: Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.

The language of the statement opposing Proposition 8 states that "the freedom to marry is fundamental to our society, just like the freedoms of religion and speech." Well, let's grant that it is fundamental just like religion and speech. Both those freedoms, despite their "fundamental" status are regulated. Religions can't endorse candidates (and remain tax exempt), and certain practices (such as polygamy) can't be practiced even when their proponents cite religious motivations. Speech: yelling "fire", swearing up a storm in public, perjury. These rights have limitations places upon them by government. And they are "fundamental" rights. But is marriage a fundamental right? Here's my guess: no, since it doesn’t show up anywhere in the Bill of Rights.

What limitations does government, aside from the issue at hand, currently place on marriage? Here are the few I came up with. Age restrictions: under a certain age no marriage period, over than age and under a slightly higher age, marriage with the permission of the parents, over that higher age get married at will. Relations: brothers and sisters can't get married, parents and children can't get married. First cousins can't get married, although even in Western societies this has been actually been practiced frequently. Numerical restrictions: a man who is married to one woman cannot marry a second while married to the first and the same holds while swapping the genders. And currently in the vast majority of states: a man cannot marry another man, and a woman cannot marry another woman.

The sexual acts involved (incest, sodomy, adultery) have been or are illegal in all states at some point in time. Gay-marriage gets a push because our society has become more accepting of the underlying acts. The case of polygamy is interesting. Adultery has been legal or effectively legal for a long, long time now. So in that case, the sexual act is no problem, but couple the sexual acts with a marriage-like relationship and it becomes a crime. Interesting, isn't it?

Age restrictions I won't bother with as I think they are the least related to the point I'm trying to make.

Family Relations: At one point in Western society cousins getting married was no problem. It was a way to strengthen family ties. Now it's a crime in many states and most everyone now think it's "gross". Brother-sister is admittedly different. But, imagine two siblings adopted into separate families who later meet each other, date, and marry without realizing they are siblings. "How gross!"?

The most common argument is a genetic one: they'll have freak-babies. Well, it's still extremely unlikely that there will be a genetic problem. Additionally, we don't allow such genetic arguments to work in other instances. Show me some evidence (not anecdotes) that show the frequency is radically different. On a side-note, if the genetic issues only come into play in later generations, then you’ve provided a reason to ban later generations from marrying not the first one.

Numerical Restrictions: Polygamy is still practiced in certain societies around the world and has been practiced continually for thousands of years. In the United States it's practice is associated mainly with the Mormon church of a lot time ago and currently Mormon-fundamentalist groups. Why is it punishable with jail time while adultery is tolerated, committed by high ranking politicians, and glamorized in movies and on TV? It seems to me our society has a problem of too little commitment, not too much.

I've heard it mentioned that we want the family to be a microcosm of democracy. And that in a polygamist "family" there is a radical imbalance of power, the man runs the show. How much democracy can exist when there are only two parties involved? It seems to me that in a polygamist family there would be much more democracy since more competing interests must be reconciled. Doesn't it seem more likely that the women could "team up" to assert their positions, thereby weakening the man's power? The microcosm of democracy argument is weak.

The folks arguing against the proposed constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage say things like:

REGARDLESS OF HOW ANYONE FEELS ABOUT MARRIAGE FOR GAY AND LESBIAN COUPLES, PEOPLE SHOULD NOT BE SINGLED OUT FOR UNFAIR TREATMENT UNDER THE LAWS OF OUR STATE.

PROPOSITION 8 MANDATES ONE SET OF RULES FOR GAY AND LESBIAN COUPLES AND ANOTHER SET FOR EVERYONE ELSE. That’s just not fair. OUR LAWS SHOULD TREAT EVERYONE EQUALLY.

[T]he law of our land—SHOULD GUARANTEE THE SAME FREEDOMS AND RIGHTS TO EVERYONE—NO ONE group SHOULD be singled out to BE TREATED DIFFERENTLY.

EQUALITY UNDER THE LAW IS A FUNDAMENTAL CONSTITUTIONAL GUARANTEE. Prop. 8 separates one group of Californians from another and excludes them from enjoying the same rights as other loving couples.

(I assure you the capitalization was in the original.)


Their arguments are never unique to gay marriage. The arguments are the exact same that one might make to allow incest and polygamy. If they wouldn't agree with those outcomes that follow from their arguments, they need to come up with better arguments or own up to the final result. They are banking on society’s recent moral acceptance of one versus continued moral rejection of another to give the arguments the required currency.

The classic reason appealing to a sense of justice is the story of hospital visitation rights. It’s a great appeal. Do you think gay folks should be allowed to visit their partners in the hospital in emergency situations? I do. Is marriage absolutely necessary for this? The opposition on the issue implies that domestic partnership status won’t suffice for this. I don’t run a hospital so I have a hard time seeing where the problem is coming from. Is marriage the only or best solution to this problem? I have seen no indication that it is.

If you ask a gay-marriage supporter if they also support legal approval of polygamy, they'll probably answer no. I'm sure they'll get pretty offended if you point out the incongruity of their position, but at least you know you are both standing on extremely similar ground.

Friday, October 24, 2008

Barack Obama and the World's Test

I recently heard on the radio about something John McCain said about Barack Obama. It turns out it was John McCain paraphrasing Joe Biden. Here's a link to the story in the Washington Post.

Here's what Biden said:

"Mark my words. It will not be six months before the world tests Barack Obama like they did John Kennedy. The world is looking. We're about to elect a brilliant 47-year-old senator president of the United States of America. ... Remember I said it standing here, if you don't remember anything else I said. Watch, we're gonna have an international crisis, a generated crisis, to test the mettle of this guy."


First of all, why on earth would you say that while you're trying to get the guy elected? John McCain jumped on it to bring up Obama's inexperience. (Even if you are voting for him, at least own up to that fact.)

Second, are you sure? Last time I check, the whole world wanted Barack Obama to be president. And I have more than a sneaking suspicion that it's not so that they can blow us up. I've attached a graphic from The Economist's Global Electoral College. It shows the map of the world, color coding countries to represent how self-reported "citizens" say they would vote.

Now, this "poll" is profoundly unscientific and the magazine isn't holding it out as if it were. Its numbers for the U.S. are way off, so we can be sure they are off for other countries as well. But, I seem to recall Obama's (campaign?) trip to Germany where they treated him like he was there to bring down the Berlin wall. The world wants so badly for Barack Obama to be elected. He's a democrat who wants to talk nice and play with others and his middle name is Hussein. To the rest of the world (and to a large proportion of the U.S.) he's safe.

So, is Joe Biden the world's first left-wing conspiracy theorist? "Six months", he said. I simply can't forsee any international crisis being "generated" for the purpose of testing him. Saying it while campaigning for Obama just underscores the fact that Biden (despite his abundance of experience) probably does belong in the co-pilot's chair.

Friday, October 3, 2008

Talking in Headlines.

"Look, folks, this is the most important election you've ever voted in your entire life."

"This is the most important election you will ever, ever have voted in, any of you, since 1932."

Sen. Joe Biden (born - 1942)

Have you noticed how everything has become superlative? I'm 27, so I can't remember a whole lot of elections, but if I recall correctly the last two were also the "most important." If only I were able to vote in 1932, since that one was clearly more important than this one. I suppose he just picked '32 for some parallels: major financial problems, a democrat took office who went on a spending spree. Too bad the spree already started in earnest.

Back to the subject... By definition, everything can't be superlative. Not in an absolute sense at least. That leads people to start windowing down in order to force the superlative. For example: "The unemployment rate is at its highest point in the last five years." Another option is "Yesterday's drop in the Dow Jones was one of the highest on record." That one's definitely useless, since nothing is specified but "yesterday" and "Dow Jones." Another one I heard several times during the Olympics: Michael Phelps is the greatest olympic champion of all time. I think the previous "greatest olympic champion of all time" only won 7 medals in a single Games.

Our society desperately needs a hero, like a Spiderman or a Martin Luther King, Jr., but a hero of common sense. Do you remember Napoleon Dynamite? He is the hero we need. There was a scene in the movie where Napoleon's brother said "That's probably the greatest movie of all time," and Napoleon responded,"Like anyone could even know that!" Thank you, Napoleon! Greatest olympian of all-time? "Like anyone could even know that!"

Maybe you don't think this tendency to categorizing everything as superlative is a real problem. Here's why I do: (1) I probably have some personality issues, and (2) it's headline language said for effect and not to inform. Headlines grab attention but they aren't the story.

Inflammatory superlatives just help push people to shoot $700B from the hip. $700B is more than we've spent on the war in Iraq, and about the yearly budget of the Dept of Health and Human Services which handles Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. The Treasury's proposed budget in 2006 was about $12B. Unless we're willing to sharply question superlative statements I think we're likely to be taken for a ride. On a related note. Is "toxic" debt bad? Duh, it's toxic! What am I, stupid? But you are more able to push $700B for toxic debt than for bad debt or "recklessly-initiated" debt. I'll admit "recklessly-initiated" sounds like loaded language to, but I think it's accurately descriptive, while toxic is just emotive.

Everyone knows the story of "The Boy Who Cried Wolf" for a reason: we've all stopped listening to someone because we believed we could no longer trust what they said. Maybe this isn't the source of Big Media's problem, but I think it's a good candidate. Although admittedly it's probably not the best of all time.

Saturday, September 13, 2008

Shock-jocks and the "Reality Beat"

I was watching Bill Moyers Journal last night, and there was a segment about crazy things right-wing shock-jocks (Limbaugh, Reagan, Savage, Beck) had said on the air. Although I honestly think they're all certified scoundrels, I got a bit defensive because I'm politically somewhere on the right. I felt that way for maybe a minute. The quotes the Moyers people played were outrageous and, well...shocking...things all those guys had said darn well better be offensive to the people reading this blog. If these guys believe every word that spews from their mouths, they are what you would most properly call "evil" people. Read a transcript if you'd like.
For the record, I don't think the shock-jocks believe themselves, at least not deep down. If I had to talk to people every day for a living, I'd probably say some stupid things too. But if I started saying evil things, hopefully I would have the sense to quit and get a real job.

The next segment was about "journalists on the 'reality beat'." Apparently it was now Bill Moyers turn to be an idiot:

"This helps us understand why the facts about Sarah Palin meant nothing when she suddenly materialized on the public stage, like Cinderella at the ball. You could see the convention delegates awed by the magical moment when the small-town girl, church-going hockey mom, mentored by her pastor to think upon the story of the biblical Queen Esther, became an overnight star. Leaping past "go" to the pinnacle of politics and the ultimate goal the cover of "People" magazine.

No wonder reality-based journalists are having a hard time with this story. Mythology is not their beat. But in the imagination of her tribe, Sarah Palin achieved an almost immaculate conception. Her lack of experience matters not to them. Nor do they care that her past is filled with contradictions, and nothing the press reports, no matter how grounded in fact, can shake their faith."

As he described this new media darling, I was reminded of the first media darling: Barack Obama. Am I to draw from this that an appearance on People magazine should dimish my regard for a potential VP...If that's true for VP's, I wonder if it applies to presidential candidates? As irrational as that may be, the astute Bill Moyers' answer must be "no."

The way he described Palin mirrors Obama's story so well: overnight star, convention delegates awed by the magical moment(s), achieved almost an immaculate conception, and [his] lack of experience matters not to them. Am I wrong about any of those? If I am, please point out my mistake. Maybe Bill Moyers said all those things about Barack Obama in a previous show. If he did I couldn't find it. Maybe as a primitive member of a "tribe" I'm just not smart enough to figure out where to look.

It seems that despite Mr. Moyers precious "reality beat", he too has the ability to pick out words like a hitman picks out his loaded guns. And look out reality, he knows how to use 'em! The funny thing is that I'll still watch his show before anything on Fox or CNN. Apparently nothing can shake my faith.

Wednesday, September 3, 2008

Republican National Convention High School Football Rules!

[By way of explanation: the title comes from a line in Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure in which a jock is giving a terrible speech and has a hard time closing it and even making a point. So instead, he pumps his fists and yells,"San Dimas County High School Football rules!" The audience bursts into happy applause.]

Conventions... Natalie and I stayed up to watch all of Obama's big speech, but for the most part didn't catch much of the Democrat's National Convention. We tuned in tonight to hear Gov. Palin speak. She seems like a nice enough lady, and shockingly normal. Although in the end, she talks like the rest of them. Not that that is reason enough to vote for McCain, mind you. I'm still very eager to see her debate Sen. Biden. It will be a good test for her.

Rudy Giuliani, if he spoke accurately made some good points, I guess they would be called "solid hits." Enter my problem... I don't want the election of the President of the United States to be just another football game. I want these folks running for office to aim squarely for my head, but they don't even try. At one point Giuliani said "Now let me be very specific..." and then proceeded to throw up pathetic generalizations. Aim for my head!

Palin actually said "Our opponent is against producing [the energy we need]." I'm sure Barack Obama flies around on his campaign jet thinking of ways to halt increases in energy production from wind, solar, and nuclear. What shameful non-sense! Aim for my head! Convince me with sound arguments, or at least try to fake it.

All the posturing, the cheering about nothing, the booing and jokes about the "opponents", the opportunism at innocent slip-ups and the twisting and clipping of soundbites does little but rally the fans. Palins speech was 36 minutes long. How much of that time was taken up by applause? It may as well be cable TV news for all the content it really provides in the time allotted... I said I looked forward to the debates, but I doubt they will be much more informative...

OK, so that was a downer post. Here's a link to cheer you up.

Tucker Carlson (the guy opening the Rally for the Republic) used to have a good show on PBS late at night, I liked it. Then MSNBC offered him more money to do a stupid show. I hated it. Reason to be cheerful? The show was cancelled. ;-)

Friday, August 29, 2008

McCain's VP pick has Idaho ties.

So I'm sure you've heard about McCain's "bold" VP pick: Sarah Palin. But, did you know she was born in Sandpoint, Idaho? Did you also know she was educated at the University of Idaho? Isn't Idaho great?

Well, she was a curve ball. I think this should be interesting, I can't wait to see the VP debates to see how well she can rise to the challenge. It's also interesting that there were major changes to the entry about her in Wikipedia in the days preceding the announcement...but that doesn't have much to do with Idaho.

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

Two More Chillun's Books

Sometimes when Hannah and I go to the library, I do a bit of browsing. I should probably do it more often, but sometimes I bring a book of my own, in which case Hannah has to do the book finding.

A while ago I came across There's Always Room for One More by the Schuberts. While I don't mind the absence of illustrations in the books I read to myself, I really like great illustrations in the books I read to Hannah. The watercolors of the book are what made me pick it up. I'm a sucker for animals (and have indoctrinated Hannah to be so as well), so these soft, friendly creatures make me (I mean Hannah) feel all cozy-inside.

The plot is very simple, the book is quite brief. Beaver builds a raft so that all his pals can go for rides together. As his buddies pile on one by one, the raft sinks slowly. By balancing perfectly they can all stay afloat though. But as I'm sure you may have surmised, balancing perfectly is hard to do.

These two have written other books as well, at least some with the same character and in the same easy-going style.

Now onto the next book...

If, like so many of us, you want your toddler to know her name, age, and party affiliation before she scurries off to preschool, allow me to recommend Why Mommy is a Democrat and its cuddly companion, Why Daddy is a Democrat.

You may think kids aren't concerned with their party identity at such a tender age, but according to Kyleigh Gruhkle (age 5), you are wrong.

The book teaches Democratic principles such "fairness, tolerance, peace, equality, and concern for the well-being of others." These two books teach such Party principles as:

"Sometimes the earth feels a little sick. Democrats make it feel better again." (see the illustration here)

"Democrats make sure we are always safe, just like mommy does." (see the illustration here)

As we all know, if children aren't taught carefully when young they are likely to do dangerous things as teenagers. For example, some teenagers have been known to send text-messages when driving, or even experiment with drugs or the Republican party. Teaching your children when they are young may help them select friends carefully to avoid such troubles.

To some extent I think these books could be a little more effective. Perhaps yet another book is in order, like Why Mommy Would Never-Ever-Forever Be a Republican or Even Have Friends Who Might Be. This book could help children understand the Republican principles of unfairness, intolerance, war, inequality, and thorough lack of concern for the well-being of others. Some illustrations might be captioned:

"Sometimes the Earth feels good. Republicans make it feel sick again."

"Republicans make sure schools are filled with evil beauraucrats and terrible teachers." (see less effective illustration)

"Republicans want policemen and firefights to stop criminals and put out fires with nothing but their bare hands." (see less effective illustration)

The message of the book is very much needed at this moment in our great nation's history. At a time when our country is so divided by a political gulf, can we afford to let our children--our future--play near the edge? I think not.

T

Monday, June 23, 2008

Alas! Poor, Rufus!

Our world recently lost one of its great, artistic contributors. I speak of Rufus, aka George Carlin. We of the Meacham Family are familiar with George Carlin from his two most profound and moving achievements, namely: the "Bill and Ted" movies, and the Thomas the Tank Engine shows.

From what I understand George Carlin was an amazingly foul-mouthed comedian. I guess he had such a wonderful vocabulary as to merit intervention by the Supreme Court of the United States of America. (Back me up, Brad.) Such fare is normally not to my liking, so I am almost entirely unfamiliar with it.

However... Hannah is a big Thomas the Tank Engine fan. Mr. Carlin was a fine (as in good enough) narrator for the many adventures of Thomas. Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure is a classic, American coming-of-age tale about two friends lost in a meaningless suburbia. Their adventures in history are both illuminating and informing. Their love for "the babes" is inspirational.

As if the those two achievements weren't enough to cement Mr. Carlin's place in our collective conscience, he brought us a sequel: Bill and Ted's Bogus Journey. In this second installment, our heroes embark on a Dantean journey unequaled since...well...Dante's? Their love for"the babes" has just blossomed into proposals of marriage, when they are violently murdered by the "evil robot uses" (pronounced "usses", as in the plural of "us"), or I suppose here it should be the "evil robot thems." And it is this love that powers them from the depths of Hell, with its hair-raising encounters with Death himself, to the very heights of Heaven itself.

In their final triumph over a mad-man threatening to destroy the near utopian future, they gently remind us that "God gave rock'n'roll to you, gave rock'n'roll to you, gave rock'n'roll to everyone." Isn't it just so true?

So whatever lesser "achievements" Mr. Carlin may have to his name, in his honor I salute you thusly:

"Be excellent to each other" and "Party on, dudes"!

Monday, June 16, 2008

The Revolution: A Manifesto

I guess the revolution really won't be fully televised. It might get a few minutes on TV, and it might get some coverage in the back of the newspaper.

This is my review of Ron Paul's The Revolution: A Manifesto. I voted for Rep. Paul in the Republican primary, and frankly I'm very likely to vote for him again in November.

The book is a simple, easy read. Paul talks about the current state of politics in America. He talks about the first century of foreign policy as well as the second century, which was very different. The concept of blowback in relation to more than just military actions but also military inactions (having hundreds of thousands of troops stationed all over the world) is explained. He also talks about it specifically in relation to 9/11, addressing the "why" question without settling for "they hate us for our freedoms" or "they hate us because we are immoral infidels."

He uses the simple illustration of sugar tariffs to introduce a chapter on economic freedom. Paul is a big proponent of free trade: free as in no government agreements required. In America since looting is allowed, every special interest tries as hard as it can to get its unfair share. Since you can, why not? People have come to think of redistribution of wealth in terms of Robin Hood. But in America the analogy breaks down. When you take from rightful owners and give to others you aren't helping, you're stealing. Intentions, however noble, don't alter the fact. As I'm sure everyone will agree, not everything the government does is legal.

As you may imagine, the Federal Reserve is called to task. It's interesting to think about in light of recent troubles. In part the Fed's job was to prevent things like the housing bubble. And let's just consider for a bit. If the Fed hadn't cut rates so much artificially than how many people would have had such an easy time getting homes that they couldn't afford? Isn't it nice that the Fed (an unelected body intended to be non-partisan) has so much control. So the Fed is supposed to prevent inflation while it's at it, but just ask your parents how much their first car cost. I'm afraid the Fed hasn't managed in that spot either. Why not have the market set rates?

I talked with my two of my brothers about these issues and others raised in the book this past weekend. One brother kept insisting that people don't really want to be free and responsible for themselves. And I think there are definitely some people that fit that bill. But I think the concept really appeals to folks. It certainly appealed to Franklin, Washington, Henry, Jefferson, Madison, Adams.

Consider this simple question: if the government were to eliminate all its welfare programs (social security, medicare, medicaid, etc.), would you be more or less likely to donate your time and money to your fellow man? We often forget that people got along without massive government looting for a long time. Once upon a time, doctors and lawyers (and most other professions) donated time and skill. Once upon a time less than 50 years ago, all attorneys were basically "on-call" to defend people that couldn't afford a lawyer. I guess people just differ on what it would be like to do it again. My vote's for "let's do it." Do you think education would really be worse if states could do their own thing and not have to spend education dollars supporting a federal bureaucracy on top of it all?

Lately we've heard numerous cries for government to "fix" the cost of gas. What else do we want government to fix for us? Government "fixes" like social security are problems. Please check this message from the Social Security and Medicare Board of Trustees. Way to go government! Let's see what else can we get you to fix for us, it's so much easier to just sit on our duffs.

Some people don't care much for Ron Paul, because of his stance on drugs. Ever wonder why there had to be an amendment to the Consistitution to make alcohol illegal (and to make it legal again), but we now have lots of drugs that are illegal with no such "laborious" efforts? I'm ready to try something new. I haven't heard of a lot of success in the "war on drugs." Einstein's definition of insanity keeps coming to mind.

I'm sure most of you already have your minds set on Obama or McCain. I'm sure both of them have great plans for balancing the budget while expanding spending on welfare (Obama) or "defense" spending (McCain). Obama had a Bilderberger picking his VP, obviously the traditional Washington connections can wrap him up just as easily as the next guy. I am not sure on the war in Iraq, it's hard for me to think we should just say "Sorry we wrecked your country...Best of luck with that!" But history will want to repeat itself, and I don't trust Obama or McCain to keep the U.S. out of the next version. Obama's pull-out promise will likely fade completely once he's in. A vote for either of them is a vote to continue policies that hurt our nation and will make things harder for your children.

During Ralph Nader's bid for the presidency in 2000 (the one where he was considered inconsequential and thus not invited to debates and later blamed for Gore's loss) Michael Moore said something I completely agree with. "If you are voting for the lesser of two evils, you are still voting for evil." (Just for your info, Mr. Moore changed his tune completely for the 2004 election.)

I highly (and seriously) recommend The Revolution.

T

P.S. I did really appreciate Pell grants...