A while ago on The Economist, I read a very interesting "Correspondent's Diary" about teaching financial literacy at a homeless shelter for women. The correspondent volunteered to teach a week-long course on basic household finance at the shelter. It was her first time volunteering since she was in school. Her justification reflected her training: "I always justified not volunteering by figuring that my actual time was worth less to the charity than the monetary value of my time." This volunteer was obviously coming from a unique perspective, you could describe it as uncaring, but at least its not parentalistic.The article goes through the discussions of each session. The author mentioned the women that came and talked about their personalities and problems. One thing that came up predictably was the use of cellphones. Apparently all these homeless women have cellphones, and most of them are on monthly plans. The author gave up trying to convince them that cellphones were a luxury, but did direct them to prepaid phones.
One thing I found very interesting was her recommendation that poor people ("liquidity constrained agents") not even try saving for retirement. They will get more from Social Security than they could possible save. She also said they don't need to bother saving for their children's college education since their children will qualify for so much financial aid. So basically they should put what little money they do have into their children's education now, for which financial aid isn't available, so they will get to college.
The installments of the diary were interesting because they reminded me that even though these school years are lean times, we still have no idea what it's like to be "genuinely poor." We can budget, we know pretty well the difference between wants and needs, we are both educated, I'm attending more school and will be able to make enough money when I get a job in just a few years to meet our needs and pay back our student loans. So despite the fact that our income is currently very low we aren't really poor. These two condition aren't synonymous.
I think Philadelphia has been helpful as well in illustrating that point. I don't mean to belittle genuinely poor people by diminishing the things we have in common or to think that I'm a better person because I'm not really like them. But I am trying to have a certain amount of respect for the differences between chronic poverty and temporary "illiquidity." When taking a wide-angle view the differences are extremely significant, so much so that the two conditions should never be confused. Which of the two conditions would you rather be in? That's how different they really are.
