Maybe it's just me, but the economic news has taken a turn for the worse. Either that or the amount of air time dedicated to it has filled the void of left by election season coverage.The other night on the News Hour there was a story about the more recent moves of the government to prevent "disaster." I think I am becoming more convinced that things could get very bad indeed. One of the reasons why I think that is that I see the government's attempts to "restore" the economy not to correct it. It seems the goal is to turn the clock back to right before the bubble ended and then freeze it there.
In a clip Henry Paulson said, "Millions of Americans cannot find affordable financing for their basic credit needs. And credit card rates are climbing, making it more expensive for families to finance everyday purchases. This lack of affordable consumer credit undermines consumer spending and, as a result, weakens our economy."
That caught my ear. What are "basic credit needs"? I understand everyone needs credit for their house, and most people purchase cars in a way that necessitates credit. But that's it, right? That is not what Paulson thinks. "Consumer spending" encompasses much more than a house and a car, but he thinks the lack of credit available for those other "needs" weakens our economy. It seems to me the over availability of credit for those things is really what got us here. A strong economy apparently doesn't mean people can afford things, but that they can borrow money for things they can't afford. They can "finance" their everyday purchases, not pay for them.
In the segment a Harvard professor, and former IMF chief economist, Kenneth Rogoff said, "Well, the whole financial system's still imploding, and it's really on life support, and we're seeing the Fed have to step in to do basic functions for this financial system. They're giving money to the banks, but the banks aren't really actively lending, so they're having to get out and support the credit markets tremendously."
Banks make money by lending, as far as I know that's the only way they make money. Why would banks not want to make money? Why would they just keep the money the Fed is sending their way? For the exact same reason that lots of folks didn't "properly use" their stimulus checks (and why future "economic stimulus" may not be in check-to-taxpayer form): to pay off debt and/or to save. Banks have to have such "debt" to make money, but they get to call it leverage. Leverage is a ratio of the total money loaned out to the total deposits.
The Economist said, "[The current economic crisis is] a radical reassessment of what constitutes acceptable levels of capital, leverage and interest rates is underway. Those financial institutions that have not failed are intent on reducing leverage—their volume of loans for each dollar of capital. The Fed has no hope of stopping this process; it is merely trying to slow it down by providing a home for the assets that the financial sector is shedding."
So consumers and banks are doing the same thing, trying to correct a real problem. Consumers with too much debt are in a precarious position, banks with too much leverage (or maybe the phrase is "too little"?) are too. It seems to me like the proposed solution to fix the economic crisis is for banks and consumers to forget reality and do exactly what they shouldn't. This is some kind of logic puzzle in which if every individual does what is right for himself, everyone will get hurt. Conversely, if every individual jeopardizes himself, we'll all be okay.
I have a hard time comforting myself with that. Partially because I think that position is aimed at restoring the bubble. But since bubbles are by definition unsustainable, trying to restore one is absurd. Restore it so it can burst again? Housing prices needed to fall, they were simply overvalued, the supply overdeveloped.
So how do you slow down the bursting of a bubble? I realize now how good the "bubble" metaphor is. Bubbles have a pretty, iridescent surface with nothing of substance on the inside. And they don't unravel, they burst. I don't know that government shouldn't try to ease the transition, but I am not convinced the transition can really be eased. If we restore the bubble, it will certainly burst again later. Maybe the government doesn't need to start harping on saving this instant, but at least they should stop telling us all that our patriotic duty is to get into debt.
