Sentimentality does no harm when it is confined to the private sphere....But as the wellspring of public policy, or of public reaction to events or social problems, it is as disastrous as it is prevalent.
Theodore Dalrymple, an Englishman, spent the bulk of his career as a psychiatrist/prison doctor for many years and has been writing for quite a while as well. His work gives an interesting perspective to this book, and I suspect his other writing as well.
First, Dalrymple is not saying that emotions are bad. In fact he says emotions are "necessary to all cognitive activity and rational thought. Without an emotional stance to the world, one would do nothing, think nothing and seek nothing."
But the book's premise is that we've let emotion run amok. More precisely, we've let public expressions of emotions run amok. "It is no longer enough to shed a tear in private over the death of Little Nell; it is necessary to do so, or the modern equivalent, in full public view.... In such a world, what is done or happens in private is not done or has not happened at all, at least not in the fullest sense." For Facebook users, think about how many times you've been "asked" to prove your support for child-abuse victims, Jesus, or America by reposting.
Saturday, June 11, 2011
Friday, May 27, 2011
Friends
Tuesday, May 24, 2011
Sunday, May 22, 2011
Baby Adrienne Pearl
We have all been anxiously awaiting the arrival of this little one. I scheduled with my doctor to be induced May 11th, which was four days before my due date, to make sure Taylor (and the rest of us if possible) would make it to his graduation from law school. I was hoping I would have her before then, but no such luck. It was nice to have my mom here and ready to take care of Hannah and Maddie. We nearly got sent home that morning, which ended up being a super busy day for babies, but my doctor got us a room and she was born healthy and beautiful a few hours later.









The girls can't stop kissing and touching her and saying how cute she is. It's cute to a point. ;-) We are all doing well and glad she is here.
Friday, May 20, 2011
Last family outing as a family of four
So much to blog that has happened in the last couple of weeks...
This is our last outing all together before the babe was born on May 6th. We are at the Schuylkill Nature Center, which has a small visitors center and a bunch of trails and ponds and such.

We mostly saw frogs and tadpoles. Taylor saw a couple of turtles in the distance and some birds. It was a beautiful day and beautiful scenery.



More excitement to come!
This is our last outing all together before the babe was born on May 6th. We are at the Schuylkill Nature Center, which has a small visitors center and a bunch of trails and ponds and such.
More excitement to come!
Friday, May 6, 2011
Review: "I Am a Promise: The Children of Stanton Elementary School"
We got I Am a Promise: The Children of Stanton Elementary School (1993) on a whim at the library. We both saw Waiting for Superman a while ago and I watched The Lottery on Hulu before that. I think education policy is very interesting. I am a real believer in education as a key to social-mobility. I also am glad I could just attend my neighborhood schools my whole life.
However, I don't think education (at least the in-school kind) is the key to social-mobility. Some of this is because, while I frankly admire schooler reformers like Geoffrey Canada, the KIPP guys, and Michelle Rhee who make waves in their own ways, none of them has the full solution. Well, Canada seems closer in some ways as I'll explain.
If you haven't seen Waiting for Superman (or The Cartel or The Lottery, or some other one) let me sum up. The shows follow the stories of a few bright kids whose parent are desperately trying to get them into a better school. We feel sad when it doesn't happen, we feel happy when it does. In the meantime we are told that teachers' unions are the big baddy that's crushing American education. Don't get me wrong, I buy the "teachers' unions are not serving children" bit hook-line-and-sinker. But there are limits to the reforms that none of those shows seem to acknowledge, that few "reformers" seem to want to acknowledge. If you want to get an idea of how those limits might play out, watch I Am a Promise. I think its probably worth more of your time than Waiting for Superman.
I Am a Promise is about the people at one school in North Philly. The neighborhood around the school is rife with poverty of all kinds. The area is blighted and overrun with crime of various kinds. The families struggle to stay together and keep it together. We meet some of the kids at the school, but they aren't the "stars" like in the reform movie, they are kids. The principal is there at 6:00AM, who knows when she leaves at night, and she's in on weekends as well. Most of the kids have presumably well-intentioned, but seemingly inept, parents. Some parents are drug-addicts. The teachers talk to the kids about what to do if a person with a gun comes into their house. There are a lot of special-ed kids, but its clear that a lot of them are in there for behavioral issues, not real mental delays.
I Am a Promise is about the people at one school in North Philly. The neighborhood around the school is rife with poverty of all kinds. The area is blighted and overrun with crime of various kinds. The families struggle to stay together and keep it together. We meet some of the kids at the school, but they aren't the "stars" like in the reform movie, they are kids. The principal is there at 6:00AM, who knows when she leaves at night, and she's in on weekends as well. Most of the kids have presumably well-intentioned, but seemingly inept, parents. Some parents are drug-addicts. The teachers talk to the kids about what to do if a person with a gun comes into their house. There are a lot of special-ed kids, but its clear that a lot of them are in there for behavioral issues, not real mental delays.
Tuesday, May 3, 2011
Random Thoughts
Presidential Exploratory Committees - In recent weeks Mitt Romney, Ron Paul, Rick Santorum, Tim Pawlenty and others have made formal announcements that they are forming "Presidential Exploratory Committees." Have these always been around as things worthy of formal announcements? Maybe it's the weakening of the party system to support candidates that causes the new importance, if it is new. But, seriously, these guys all have PACs that have been collecting money during the "off-season", and now they form these pre-campaign fund-raising vehicle to decide if they can get enough money to run, i.e. start actual campaign fund-raising. I guess too much money is on the line to just run.
The Royal Wedding - I was a little bugged when Google didn't do a Doodle for St. Patty's day a while back. Then on the day of the big wedding in England, all of America got to see a celebratory doodle? I can understand doing this for users in the UK, but for Pete's sake, this is the U.S.A. People fought and died to rid ourselves of the English monarchy and now that a prince getting married we're supposed to just overlook it all, because it's some kind of real life fairy-tale? I can't figure out how the English still stand for it. Is their national identity so tied up in support of kings, queen, princes, princesses, dukes, and duchesses, etc, that they can't give the moochers the boot? Short answer: yes. I still don't understand it.
Osama bin Laden - So, umm, can we ease up at the airport now that "the world is safer"?
The Royal Wedding - I was a little bugged when Google didn't do a Doodle for St. Patty's day a while back. Then on the day of the big wedding in England, all of America got to see a celebratory doodle? I can understand doing this for users in the UK, but for Pete's sake, this is the U.S.A. People fought and died to rid ourselves of the English monarchy and now that a prince getting married we're supposed to just overlook it all, because it's some kind of real life fairy-tale? I can't figure out how the English still stand for it. Is their national identity so tied up in support of kings, queen, princes, princesses, dukes, and duchesses, etc, that they can't give the moochers the boot? Short answer: yes. I still don't understand it.
Osama bin Laden - So, umm, can we ease up at the airport now that "the world is safer"?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
