A week or two ago, news broke in the New York Times that Disney was going to start offering refunds of $15.99 for Baby Einstein videos that failed to satisfy purchasers. That is, if they were sold after June of 2004.So why 2004? According to this AP article, it's because that's when lawyers working with the Campaign for a Commercial Free Childhood first contacted the Baby Einstein folks.
Quick background on the two groups at issue:
Baby Einstein - founded by a mother and former educator, sells...well, they used to be "developmental products" but aren't anymore, sold to Disney several years ago.
Campaign for a Commercial Free Childhood - a self-described group of folks "who care about children." They seem to be mostly academics with children. Picture Bratz dolls, and picture a horde of angry smarty-pants that want to "wipe them off that map," as Ahmadinejad would say.
Years ago the CCFC began hounding Baby Einstein and the FTC about the claims Baby Einstein made. Please click this link to see some of the CCFC's gripes. Sometimes I think the CCFC gets a little crazy, but I think their hearts are pretty well in the right place.
Natalie and I talked about it a bit. She mentioned that few people probably made their purchases thinking that the videos really would make their kids smarter. (Darn that Matsui!) She's got a good point. But did the false claims appease the guilt of someone who really wanted an electronic pacifier, but otherwise wouldn't have purchased Baby Einstein.
I don't think a lot of folks are going to be taking them up on the offer, unless they have a stack their kids have outgrown and they have no scruples. But it's an interested pseudo-admission in light of past marketing. If it eliminates the false claims now, will a reputation still prevail? It is called "Baby Einstein" after all.
Note: we own Baby Mozart and frequently check out Baby Einstein movies from the library. I think they are better than some shows targeting little kids. We won't be asking for a refund, but I'm glad the CCFC is being a good gadfly.


